Fluids

Better Pin-Fin Cooling for Power Electronics Engineers

Independent analysis by Starro. Not client work.

A copper cold plate with rows of short round pins and coolant flowing between them

Objective

Best Use of a Fixed Pressure Budget

Pin-fin cold plates pull heat out of power modules, batteries and compute hardware. Every design trades thermal resistance against pressure drop, and the pump budget is often the real limit.

For a fixed pressure budget, which pin layout gives the lowest thermal resistance: more flow, denser pins or staggered pins?

Findings

Denser Inline Pins Beat More Flow

The baseline inline plate (3 mm pins at 6 mm pitch, 6 mm tall) has 11.3 K/kW at 1.43 kPa. Doubling the flow lowers this to 7.6 K/kW, while spending the same pressure drop, about 6 kPa, on a denser inline field at the original flow reaches 5.9 K/kW.

Staggered pins transfer slightly more heat at equal geometry but need about twice the pressure drop. At equal pressure drop, inline layouts match or beat them in this range.

Thermal resistance and pressure drop against pin diameter for inline and staggered layouts at a pitch of two diameters.

Approach

Correlation Sweep of 136 Pin Designs

A representative 100 × 50 mm copper pin plate carrying 1.5 kW with 50/50 glycol at 8 L/min. The trade is mapped across 136 inline and staggered designs using the Žukauskas heat transfer and Gaddis–Gnielinski pressure-drop correlations, with fin efficiency and effectiveness.

Pin-fin cold plate: inline and staggered pin layouts in top view, and a side view with the module baseplate above.

Validation

Fin Solution and Energy Balance Checks

How we checked the model:

  • Pin fin efficiency matches a finite-difference fin solution: 0.6067 against 0.6067.

  • A marching energy balance along the plate recovers 1500.2 W of the 1500 W applied.

  • The Gaddis–Gnielinski correlation is implemented term by term from its published form and agrees in order with the Žukauskas charts.

Recommendations

Compare Layouts at Equal Pressure Drop

Spend the pressure budget on the pin field, not on more flow. Compare layouts at equal pressure drop, not equal geometry, or staggered pins will look better than they are. A correlation sweep like this narrows the design before detailed CFD or a prototype.

Tools used:

Žukauskas and Gaddis–Gnielinski correlations; fin efficiency and effectiveness across 136 designs