Structural

Lighter, Proven Wing Spars for UAV Structures Teams

Independent analysis by Starro. Not client work.

A slender carbon-fiber wing spar resting on a test stand with load pads along its length

Objective

Spar Mass for a Small UAV Wing

Small UAV wing spars are often off-the-shelf tubes of constant diameter, sized by habit. A spar that follows the load can save most of its mass, but only if the loads and the proof test are credible.

How much spar mass does a small UAV need, and what sets it: material, depth or stiffness?

Findings

Section Depth Matters More Than Material

The root bending moment at the 4 g limit is 311 N·m. A constant 25 mm aluminum tube weighs 3.46 kg and a constant carbon tube 0.97 kg. Following the airfoil depth cuts the carbon spar to 0.31 kg, 68 % less, and a tapered aluminum tube (0.90 kg) still beats the constant carbon one.

For light designs, stiffness and minimum gauge, not strength, set the mass. A four-point whiffletree per wing half reproduces the design bending moment within 1 % of its root value, which gives a simple, credible proof test.

Limit bending moment along the spar and the moment produced by a four-point static test rig, matching within 1 %.

Approach

Lifting-Line Loads to Spar Sizing and Proof Test

A 25 kg, 3.6 m tapered wing taken from lifting-line loads, solved by Glauert's method and scaled to a 4 g limit with a 1.5 factor of safety, to spar sizing and a static test rig. Circular aluminum and carbon spars are sized for strength, local buckling and a tip deflection limit of 10 % of semi-span.

Wing planform with the spar line, and lift per unit span at the 4 g limit from lifting-line theory compared with an elliptic distribution.

Validation

Exact Elliptic-Wing and Beam Solutions

How we checked the model:

  • Elliptic-wing lift matches the exact solution: lift coefficient 0.47388 against 0.47388, span efficiency 1.0000.

  • The lift series converges: the spanwise centroid moves 0.9 % from 40 to 320 terms.

  • Beam integration matches the closed-form cantilever deflection.

  • Root shear equals half the net lift: 431.5 N.

Recommendations

Taper the Spar Before Paying for Carbon

Section depth matters more than material: taper the spar with the airfoil before paying for carbon. Size for deflection and minimum gauge as well as strength, and plan the proof test with the design; a four-point rig per half loads the spar as it will fly.

Tools used:

Lifting-line loads (Glauert); beam sizing for strength, buckling and deflection; static test rig design